Allswell vs Puffy vs Tuft & Needle vs Saatva vs DreamCloud (Review Guide)

By | June 3, 2023

Looking for a new mattress can be overwhelming, especially with so many options available on the market. Allswell, Puffy, Tuft & Needle, Saatva, and DreamCloud are some of the popular choices that offer a range of features and benefits. In this review guide, we’ll compare these five mattress brands and help you choose the one that meets your needs and preferences. So, read on to find out which mattress comes out on top in this ultimate mattress showdown!

Allswell vs Puffy vs Tuft & Needle vs Saatva vs DreamCloud (Review Guide)

Mattresses are undoubtedly one of the most crucial investments we make for our personal wellbeing. A good mattress can ensure a comforting and peaceful sleep, which significantly impacts our overall health. With the rise of online mattress companies and their bed-in-a-box models, selecting an ideal quality mattress has become a bit challenging. In this review guide, we will compare Allswell, Puffy, Tuft & Needle, Saatva, and DreamCloud based on their construction, feel, and support, catering explicitly to different types of sleepers.


Allswell, Puffy, Tuft & Needle, Saatva, and DreamCloud are five of the leading mattress brands available in the market, and each offers unique sleeping solutions to satisfy different kinds of sleepers. Some excellent features that these mattresses boast include motion isolation, pressure relief, cooling properties, durability, and bounce.

However, what distinguishes these brands from one another is their composition and the way they cater to different sleeping positions. Therefore, we have reviewed and compared these mattresses to help you determine which one suits your sleeping style the best.



Allswell has a hybrid construction consisting of memory foam and pocketed coils. The mattress has a height of 10 inches and comes with different firmness levels. The firmness options include plush, medium-firm, and firm accompanied by a top layer quilted with foam and high-quality fabrics, allowing for maximum comfort.


Puffy has two variants: Puffy and Puffy Lux. Both have a similar makeup, having three layers. The top layer is a cooling cloud foam layer, followed by a temperature-sensitive memory foam layer and a sturdy base foam layer for support.

Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle is an all-foam mattress made with two layers of open-cell polyfoam that promote breathability. The mattress also features graphite and gel-infused layers to prevent heat retention.


Saatva is a sturdy, durable innerspring hybrid mattress made with coil-on-coil construction. It includes a Euro pillow-top layer and a layer of foam to provide adequate support and comfortable cushioning.


DreamCloud has a unique composition, with eight layers of varying materials, including gel-infused foam, memory foam, natural latex, and microcoil technology. Each layer serves a specific purpose to provide exceptional comfort and support to sleepers.

Feel and Firmness


Despite Allswell’s construction featuring innerspring coils, the mattress provides a reasonably comfortable, plush feel. The mattress has a universal pressure point relief feature, catering to all sleeping styles. Its firmness level varies from plush to firm, suiting individual requirements.


Puffy mattresses exclusively use memory foam, ensuring minimal motion transfer, making it an excellent option for couples. Puffy’s firmness level of 5-6 provides overall comfort, making it ideal for all sleeping positions. The mattress is also known for its soft, cloud-like feel.

Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle’s mattress is ideal for those looking for a medium-firm mattress to prevent back pain. The foam used in the mattress conforms to a sleeper’s body shape, making it suitable for various sleeping styles.


Saatva’s mattress has a medium-firm feel, providing a comfortable cushioning effect with the Euro pillow layer. It is unique in that it comes in three different firmness levels, catering to all types of sleepers.


DreamCloud’s firmness level of 6.5 offers a comfortable yet supportive feel suitable for all sleeping positions. The use of eight layers enhances motion isolation and pressure relief.

Construction, Feel, and Support for Specific Sleeping Positions

Side Sleepers

For side sleepers, mattresses with pressure relief and a plush feel are ideal.

  • Allswell: The plush option is suitable for side sleepers, providing adequate support to the shoulders and hips.
  • Puffy: The soft, cloud-like feel allows for enhanced pressure relief to the shoulders and hips.
  • Tuft & Needle: The all-foam construction features pressure relief for the hips and shoulders.
  • Saatva: The plush soft mattress offers excellent pressure relief for side sleepers while also cushioning their body.
  • DreamCloud: The all-around comfort in the luxury firm option is ideal for side sleepers.

Stomach Sleepers

For stomach sleepers, a firm mattress providing support to the lower back is best.

  • Allswell: The firm option provides reliable support to the lower back and prevents sinkage.
  • Puffy: The variant offers a proper balance of comfort and support to stomach sleepers.
  • Tuft & Needle: The sturdy base foam layer ensures adequate support to the lower back.
  • Saatva: The medium-firm mattress provides even support to all parts of the body, including the lower back.
  • DreamCloud: The medium-firm mattress conforms to the sleepers’ shape, providing support to the lower back.

Back Sleepers

For back sleepers, a medium-firm mattress with adequate lumbar support is the best option.

  • Allswell: The medium-firm option provides lumbar support.
  • Puffy: Both the original and lux variants offer an excellent balance of comfort and support.
  • Tuft & Needle: The open-cell construction provides equal weight distribution and lumbar support.
  • Saatva: The luxury firm mattress’s comfort layer conforms to the spine’s natural curve, optimizing lumbar support.
  • DreamCloud: The plush option is ideal for back sleepers, providing ample lumbar support and comfort.

Combination Sleepers

For combination sleepers, a mattress with a moderate level of firmness and minimal sinkage is the best option.

  • Allswell: The medium-firm option is suitable for combination sleepers, providing both comfort and support.
  • Puffy: Both the original and lux variants are suitable options for combination sleepers.
  • Tuft & Needle: The mattress’s structure ensures equal weight distribution, making it an excellent option for combination sleepers.
  • Saatva: The medium-firm mattress offers enough cushioning, making changing positions very comfortable for combination sleepers.
  • DreamCloud: The medium-firm option caters to combination sleepers, ensuring maximum comfort and support.


Allswell, Puffy, Tuft & Needle, Saatva, and DreamCloud all offer quality mattresses with unique features to cater to different types of sleepers. The ideal mattress for each sleeper will depend on their weight, sleeping position, and personal preferences.

We have discussed the mattress construction, feel, and support, catering explicitly to different sleeping positions, and we hope that this guide will help you make an informed decision about your next mattress purchase.


1. Can I try these mattresses before purchasing them?

Most online mattress companies offer a trial period, which allows you to test drive the mattress for a particular period before making the purchase.

2. How long do these mattresses last?

Allswell and Puffy mattresses typically have a lifespan of around seven years, while Saatva and Tuft & Needle can last up to ten years. DreamCloud mattresses have a lifespan of around eight years.

3. Is it safe to purchase these mattresses online?

Yes, purchasing mattresses online is safe, especially if you opt for a brand that offers a trial period and easy returns.

4. Can I use my existing box spring with these mattresses?

It is recommended to use the box spring recommended by the manufacturer, as using an inappropriate box spring may void the warranty.

5. What if I don’t like the mattress after purchasing it?

Most online mattress companies offer a sleep trial period, which allows you to test the mattress before making the purchase. In case you are dissatisfied with your purchase, you can opt for a return or exchange within the trial period.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *